Establishing A Modern Multimodal Transportation System

As a mature region, Greater Philadelphia's transportation system is largely built out. The focus now is on maintaining and preserving the system and improving its efficiency. With limited funding for new capacity expansion, the Connections 2040 Plan recommends making the transportation system more functional through Intelligent Transportation Systems (ITS) improvements and land use decisions that support alternative modes of transportation to optimize investments.
Multimodal Transportation
Greater Philadelphia benefits from a strong multimodal transportation system. Connections 2040 plans to strengthen and enhance the multimodal aspects of the region's transportation infrastructure through maintenance programs and targeted expansion. Increasing transportation sustainability can be done by encouraging environmentally friendly alternative forms of transportation, such as walking, biking, and transit. Compact development patterns, particularly transit-oriented and mixed-use development, increase accessibility between origins and destinations. Providing facilities, such as sidewalks, bike lanes, and multi-use trails, as well as improving transit service, can help to encourage the use of these modes. Municipal tools to help build a modern, multimodal network include:
Context-Sensitive Design/Context-Sensitive Solutions
Context-sensitive design/context-sensitive solutions recognize that roadway improvements should not incorporate a one-size-fits-all approach, but should instead reflect their surrounding land use. Depending on whether the roadway is in an urban, suburban, or rural area affects the roadway width, presence of parking, and appropriate speed limit.
- For More Information
Community Shuttle Programs
Community shuttle programs can complement existing public transit service by providing services to special populations, such as senior citizens, or by circulating within neighborhoods that are not served by transit. Community shuttles can be operated by transportation management associations or other nonprofit organizations and are often funded through job access or elderly programs.
Park-and-Ride Programs
Park-and-ride programs encourage the use of transit and car pooling, thus lowering congestion on roadways by providing parking areas near transit stops. Park-and-ride facilities are sometimes located in the parking lots of businesses or institutions and are based on negotiations between the municipality, the transit provider, and the landowner.
Sidewalk Standards
Sidewalk standards in a municipal subdivision and land development ordinance require that sidewalks be included on all subdivision and site development plans. Developers may argue that it does not make sense to build unconnected "sidewalks to nowhere," but unless they are included in subdivision and site development plans, a sidewalk network will never get started.
Sidewalk Management
Sidewalk management ensures that sidewalks are free of obstacles and well maintained. Sidewalk design should follow Federal Highway Administration and American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials recommendations of a 10' minimum width divided into four zone system: frontage zone (30" next to building), pedestrian zone (60"), planter/furniture zone (24" minimum, 48" with street trees), and curb zone (6").
A sidewalk assessment program should document conditions, prioritize improvements, and determine where maintenance is needed. Maintenance should ensure that the sidewalk remains as even as possible. In Pennsylvania, maintenance responsibility is largely on property owners. Some jurisdictions have adopted alternative ways to fund sidewalk maintenance, such as the municipality performing the construction and the resident paying for materials in Charlotte, North Carolina; and Madison, Wisconsin, has a 50/50 plan in which repair costs are split between the city and property owners. In both cases the property owner must make the repair request.
Incorporate Transit into Development Review
Municipalities can ensure that transit access, stop placement, and bus stop design issues are considered for new development and/or redevelopment by utilizing a transit development review checklist. This checklist can be used as an advisory document or strengthened by codifying it into municipal zoning ordinances.
- For More Information
- Central Jersey Transportation Forum Development Review Checklist for Consideration of Transit [pdf]
Transportation Safety
Enhancing safety is of the utmost concern, both in terms of new facilities and addressing previous facilities designed to standards that are now outdated and may compromise safety. Careful consideration should be given to the location, frequency, type, and cause of crashes within the recent past. Tools to enhance safety on our regional roadways include:
Traffic Calming
Traffic calming techniques can reduce traffic speeds by incorporating physical elements (speed humps, narrow lanes, wide sidewalks, diagonal or parallel street parking, and central medians with landscaping) into roadway design to modify driver behavior. These are most desirable on residential streets, commercial streets, or areas with high pedestrian traffic.
- For More Information
- Case Studies
Road Safety Audit
A road safety audit is a formal safety performance evaluation of an existing or future road or intersection by an independent, qualified safety team. It qualitatively estimates and reports on potential road safety issues and identifies opportunities for safety improvements, while determining if the needs of all road users are being safely met.
- Case Studies
Complete Streets
Complete Streets design standards make roads safer and more user-friendly for bicyclists, pedestrians, the disabled, the elderly, and drivers by including wide sidewalks, bicycle lanes, raised crosswalks and medians, audible traffic signals, bus pullouts, and any other design elements that support safe, alternative transportation.
- For More Information
- New Jersey Department of Transportation Complete Streets Policy
- National Complete Streets Coalition
- Philadelphia Complete Streets Handbook

Road Diets
Road diets are usually conversions of four-lane undivided roads into three lanes (two travel lanes and a continuous two-way left-turn lane). The remaining pavement width from the eliminated lane can be converted into bicycle lanes, sidewalks, on-street parking, or some combination of these elements.
Shared Space/Living Streets
A living street is a street designed primarily with the interests of pedestrians and cyclists in mind and as a social space where people can meet and where children may also be able to play legally and safely. These roads are still available for use by motor vehicles; however, their design aims to reduce both the speed and dominance of motorized transport by minimizing demarcations, such as curbs, road surface markings, traffic signs, and regulations.
- For More Information
- Model Design Manual for Living Streets
Coordinated Traffic Signal Systems
Traffic signal systems use timing and signal coordination to manage the flow of traffic volumes along a corridor. In municipalities where congestion is a serious concern, the possibility of implementing closed-loop traffic signal systems should be explored in coordination with the pertinent state department of transportation.
- For More Information
- Green Light-Go: Pennsylvania's Municipal Signal Partnership Program
Roundabouts
Roundabouts are circular intersections with specific design and traffic control features. Key features include yield control of entering traffic, channelized approaches, and appropriate geometric curvature to slow speeds. Roundabouts provide substantially better operational and safety characteristics than older traffic circles and rotaries and are safer than comparable signalized intersections.
Access Management
Access management provisions improve safety and efficiency on roadways by limiting and controlling access points. Access management can reduce congestion and accidents without major capital improvements by linking land use and transportation planning strategies. Access management tools may involve shared driveways for local businesses, improved signage, parallel access roads, or similar techniques. Access management can often be accomplished in conjunction with the state department of transportation's Highway Occupancy Permit process.
- For More Information
- Access Management: Model Ordinances for Pennsylvania Municipalities Handbook [pdf]
Vision Zero
Vision Zero is a multi-national road traffic safety project that views any loss of life or serious injury from road traffic as unacceptable. Vision Zero places responsibility for achieving no deaths or injuries on the design of the transportation system, not the system users.
- For More Information
- The Vision Zero Initiative
Parking Management
Municipal parking standards often assume that all trips will be made by car and that destinations will be isolated and single use in character. Such standards fail to recognize the different types of parking provisions that may be desirable or cost appropriate for different contexts, such as downtowns, suburban shopping districts, or rural areas. Municipal parking ordinances therefore often result in too much parking or requirements that are not flexible for mixed-use settings. These requirements have a strong influence on the built and natural environment and how the community grows or redevelops. Municipalities can better regulate, manage, and design parking to fit local needs by revising their local ordinances to consider the following:
Minimum/Maximum Parking Standards
Revisit Minimum Parking Standards to ensure that required parking supply does not exceed demand and is sensitive to the local context. In some cases, such as in TODs or historic villages, Parking Maximums may be needed.
Shared Parking, Reserve Parking, and Fee-in-Lieu Parking
Provide alternatives to conventional parking standards by allowing flexible parking provisions, such as shared parking, reserve parking, and fee-in-lieu of parking.
Pricing or Metering Strategies
Implement pricing or metering strategies in locations where the amount of available parking is scarce and/or parking turnover is encouraged.
- Best Practices
Dedicated and/or Preferred Parking
Provide dedicated and/or preferred parking for bicycles, vanpools, carpools, car- sharing, and low-emitting and fuel-efficient vehicles.
Sustainable Practices in Parking Design
Encourage sustainable practices in parking design, including the use of recycled concrete and asphalt, pervious paving, stormwater best practices, and heat island-preventing treatments. Redesign existing parking lots to support walkability and improve aesthetics.
- For More Information
Sustainable Transportation
Local governments can encourage new environmentally friendly technologies, which increase sustainability. These can be in the form of supporting the adoption of alternative fuel vehicles, telecommuting, car sharing, and bike sharing. The last two, in particular, lend themselves to potential public–-private partnerships and create services that reduce the need for auto ownership.
Many local governments maintain their own fleet of vehicles, ranging from heavy-duty vehicles (such as waste-hauling trucks and fire trucks) to light-duty trucks and passenger cars, including police cars. Local government fleets are excellent test beds for the introduction of alternative vehicles in the region. In many cases there are various incentives for switching to alternative fuels, which, combined with increased fuel efficiency, can further save the municipality money. Light- and heavy-duty trucks are particularly well suited to conversion to natural gas, which has the added benefit of being relatively local in nature.
Local governments can utilize travel demand management techniques for their employees. These benefits can help local governments compete for talent, reduce roadway demand during peak hours, and help make local government cleaner and greener.
Travel Demand Management (TDM)
TDM programs work to reduce traffic at peak hours by changing the driving habits of commuters. Strategies include employee subsidies for the use of transit, such as RideECO, preferred parking for car-poolers, parking fees for employees who drive alone, flex-time, telecommuting, and similar measures.
- For More Information
- RideECO
Trip Reduction Ordinances (TRO)
TROs use municipal regulatory authority to limit trip generation from development sites. They usually cover an entire local political subdivision rather than just an individual project, spreading the burden more equitably between existing and future development. They may be less vulnerable to legal challenges than conditions imposed on development approvals. Also known as Employee Trip Reduction, such approaches may be voluntary or mandatory.
Fleet Vehicle Audits
Fleet vehicle audits allow local governments to inventory current fleet vehicles and driving practices to determine where the best opportunities lie for reducing energy use in fleet vehicles. A fleet audit will assess the availability, costs, benefits, and barriers to implementation of alternative fuels and vehicles, and will help identify other fuel-saving opportunities, such as improvements to the existing fleet through vehicle maintenance and the feasibility of an early retirement program.
Purchasing Natural Gas Vehicles
School districts and municipalities may benefit from replacing diesel school buses and refuse vehicles with compressed natural gas vehicles, which have significantly lower operating costs and greenhouse gas emissions.
Encouraging Electric Vehicle Charging
Municipalities may encourage electric vehicle charging in a number of ways. They can ease the permitting of installing residential charging stations. Some municipalities have encouraged developers to install electrical conduits in parking lots of newly constructed commercial or multi-family buildings to facilitate meeting future demand for electric vehicle charging.
Cool Pavement
Cool pavement denotes materials and construction techniques selected to reduce the absorption, retention, and emitting of solar heat. It reduces the heat island effect and helps to lower air temperatures, improve air quality, and quality of life during the heat of summer. This porous/permeable paving also reduces stormwater runoff and the need for stormwater retention.
Walking and Biking Encouragement Programs
Walking and biking encouragement programs advocate sharing the road in a safe and equitable way, and promote walking and bicycling as viable transportation modes. Common efforts include Safe Routes to School (SRTS), walking school buses or trains (with parent and teacher supervision), and share-the-road campaigns.
- For More Information
Regional Transportation Funding
Lack of funding is a major challenge as we work to modernize the transportation system. The region's transportation infrastructure faces a $53 billion funding deficit over the next 25 years just to maintain the system in a state of good repair, with limited new-capacity expansion.
Pennsylvania recently passed Act 89, which will provide a significant increase in funding for transportation projects in the state. However, the New Jersey Transportation Trust Fund is nearly broke, and the Greater Philadelphia region lags behind the other largest metro areas in the United States in terms of local contribution to transportation projects. Realizing the importance of a modern multimodal transportation system and the need to invest in maintaining and improving our existing system, several counties in the region are starting to look at ways to raise transportation funding from local sources, including bonds and tolling.
One type of funding source that municipalities have the power to enforce is traffic impact fees. Both Pennsylvania and New Jersey have "partnership acts," which encourage private developer contributions to advance transportation projects. These funds often come as a result of a major development impacting the local transportation network. The rationale for such funding is that the developer's contribution (or implementation in absence of public funds) serves to speed up project delivery, resulting in enhanced overall accessibility to the development.
Municipalities can work with DVRPC and state departments of transportation to reduce the costs of transportation projects by ensuring that projects are "right-sized" in order to scale the solution to the size of the problem and tailor the approach to the specific project, and selecting transportation projects for capital programming based on sound long-range strategic planning considerations, life-cycle investment analyses, and system performance and condition data.
- For More Information